Last week I participated in a competition to give away an iPad 2.
My profile: I commute to work by train. I am an avid social media user, particularly on twitter and then facebook where I’m more a lurker than an active participant. By now you would have guessed that I am a professional, and thus I actually spend more time on LinkedIn than Facebook. I don’t listen to the radio – (1) I don’t own a portable one (2) If I did I’d likely listen to the one with three-drumsticks-beating as its logo- mainly cos I generally dislike advertisements and the morning show commentaries.
I knew about the competition because the guys and gals in orange t-shirts were giving out handouts at the train station. It was also by coincidence- I don’t normally get off at that station only that I had a meeting at a different site that Monday morning.
I also don’t normally accept these handouts, mainly because I think there is already enough wasted printed paper of ads, catalogs, junk mail, in the councils, free newspapers, etc. (should also add these two to my profile above).
But I saw the keyword on this handout.

The handout
It was only back in the office that I looked into the content, followed the links for more details and the T&C, and decided to give it a go for the remaining days of the week. I had also started paying attention to their twitter and Facebook group page updates.
They were giving away an iPad 2 each day of the week in both Sydney and Melbourne. There would be clues announced at 5:30am on the weekday mornings, and these are riddles on where / city street names to meet the crew for the chance to win for that day. They would be there between 12 noon to 1pm, and whoever got there first; and if there were more than one- whoever first answers the questions correctly would be the winner for that day for that city.
On Tuesday I followed the clue and actually did manage to find them. Only that I was on time and there was already a small queue of maybe 5 people. I didn’t stand a chance, but I did hang around to see how it was conducted. They did follow the T&C on how the ultimate winner was selected for the day.
I hung around some more and spoke to one of the guys. This exercise is to raise awareness for:
- Their name change;
- General awareness of the association;
- To (then) increase their membership.
I draw your attention to these objectives.
So naturally I started paying more attention to their only immediate means of communicating with the general public- their social media presence; for more clues, updates, buzz, participation, etc.
Wednesday came around and I had the clue wrong; because by 12:30 I still hadn’t spotted anyone in orange t-shirts, and I had to give up for an appointment at 12:30. I guess by this time there was a little more exposure to their FB page, cos there were pleas for the right answers/locations from those who obviously (like me) got it wrong.
By Thursday their site on the handout still had not included their twitter handle or their Facebook address- they had the twitter and FB logos there yet were not link-buttons- I had to work this two information out myself on Tuesday to find the correct username and page. As the days progressed updates were slow coming- it was clearly not intended to be “live” updates for its (hopefully increasing number of?) followers; only to echo the respective clues of the day, and the winners’ names as the days passed.
Somewhere along the way (Wednesday evening I believe) I was window shopping at a nearby pharmacy and did hear the radio ad for this campaign.
The followers who did find their FB page started behaving like typical FB users- they started posting conversation pieces. A few had asked for the location, commenting that answers should be shared after the 1pm closing time. Others playfully shared their hints and clues, etc. These were generally unanswered, on their FB page as well as their twitter engagement; only a few peppered congratulatory messages and photo of winners, and “wait for the end of the week” messages. It was the winner who posted “I WON” and was kind enough to reply questions on where the Wednesday location was.
Thursday was the same story for me- unfortunately I had gotten it wrong. I had also joined in asking where the correct location was, carrying on in dialogs with one or two other participants on thoughts and answers/streets. Again, “wait for the end of the week” from the organiser.

Screen shot of updates

Friday came but I was busy in the office, but was still paying attention to the way this competition was conducted.
At the end of the day, at least a few hours after 1pm, I checked all three of twitter, FB, and their website.
Their FB page were #fb repeats of their tweets, plus very few additional updates. These were generally “all won”, “congrats to all winners”. Their website did finally put up the correct respective answers for the respective days.
Nothing more was added. There were a few accounting-industry related news like who-moved-up-the-corporate-ladder-type news. Nothing related to the competition, and certainly nothing engaging at all.
So the question beckons: What was the aim and real objective of this iPad giveaway competition, other than pleasing 2x 5 persons in the respective cities?
There was minimal engagement on both twitter and FB, the only 2 obvious platforms to me as Regular Joe, on the progress of the competition, engagement with the institute, awareness of them in general. Together with their website, these were the places to find their clues-for-the-day and the photos of the daily winners.
What was achieved in leaving the answers to the end of the week, with little SM-type engagements on these SM platforms, especially when there is obviously (albeit low levels of) frustration already?
There was no attempt, at least to me, to execute their campaign- unless I heard them wrong, there was no other attempts at the three listed objectives. They did however (on Tuesday when I watched them) give out their “showbags” which contained a pen, a small corporate-brochure-like booklet, and the same train-station handout; to curious passers-by who had only chanced upon this small crowd on the curbside.
I may even go as far as to say that at least 1 of the winners chanced upon their curbside set up, asked “what’s going on?” and won.
I now wonder what level of service, member benefits, engagement, feedback etc, I would get from them if I had joined, given that they have gone out to kinda announce they are giving away iPads, but definitely offered little else about who they are in the meantime.
This is how I saw the whole campaign.